(And How Testing Can Reduce the Guesswork)
This information took me off the rollercoaster of medication trial and error. I hope everyone learns something that will help them, and improve their experience.
If you’ve ever wondered why a diabetes medication worked beautifully for someone else—and felt like absolute misery in your body—you’re not imagining things. And you’re definitely not failing.
Here’s the truth most women are never told: Type 2 diabetes medications don’t all do the same job, and women don’t all have the same underlying glucose issue. So when treatment feels like trial and error, it’s not because you’re complicated—it’s because the system is oversimplified.
This article isn’t about telling you what medication to take. It’s about helping you understand what problem a medication is trying to solve, why it may or may not match your physiology, and how a little targeted testing can dramatically reduce the guessing game.
Let’s pull back the curtain.
Type 2 Diabetes Isn’t One Problem—It’s a System
Most conversations around Type 2 diabetes focus on blood sugar numbers. But glucose is just the output, not the root issue. Under the hood, glucose regulation depends on several moving parts working together:
- How sensitive your cells are to insulin
- How much insulin your pancreas can produce
- How quickly insulin is released after eating
- How much glucose your liver releases (especially under stress)
- How digestion and absorption affect blood sugar rise
- How stress hormones influence all of the above
When any one of these systems is under strain—or when several are at once—blood sugar rises. Medications step in to support specific parts of this system. That’s where things get interesting… and where mismatch can happen.
Why One T2 Diabetes Medication Feels Like a Miracle—and Another Feels Like Hell
Let’s look at this plainly.
Metformin, for example, primarily reduces glucose output from the liver and improves insulin sensitivity. It’s often prescribed first because it’s well-studied and doesn’t usually cause low blood sugar. But if your main issue isn’t insulin resistance—and especially if your stress hormones are high—metformin can feel brutal on the gut and energy levels.
Sulfonylureas (like glimepiride) work very differently. They tell the pancreas to release more insulin. For women whose pancreases can make insulin but aren’t releasing it effectively—often due to stress or suppressed Phase 1 insulin response—this can feel like the missing piece. Until the nervous system calms down, that is.
GLP-1 medications influence appetite, digestion speed, and insulin release when glucose is present. They can be incredibly effective, but appetite suppression doesn’t automatically equal metabolic healing—especially if stress, under-eating, or muscle loss enter the picture.
SGLT-2 inhibitors lower blood sugar by pushing excess glucose out through the kidneys. They can help numbers quickly, but they don’t correct insulin signaling or production issues.
None of these are “good” or “bad.” They’re tools. And tools work best when matched to the job.
The Missing Conversation: What Part of My System Needs Support?
Here’s where most care models fall short. Instead of asking why glucose is dysregulated in a particular woman, the focus is often on what lowers A1C the fastest.
But consider this:
If insulin resistance is the main issue, pushing the pancreas harder may increase exhaustion.
If insulin production is the issue, improving sensitivity alone may not be enough.
If stress hormones are driving glucose output, any medication may feel ineffective or intolerable.
This is why two women can follow the same plan—with the same medication—and have wildly different experiences.
How Testing Can Reduce the Guesswork
No test is perfect. And no single lab tells the whole story. But the right combination of tests can clarify where support is needed, instead of guessing blindly.
Here are some of the most useful—and underutilized—tools:
Fasting Insulin
This simple blood test shows how hard your body is working to keep glucose in range. High insulin with normal glucose suggests early insulin resistance. Lower insulin with high glucose can point toward production issues.
C-Peptide
This test reveals how much insulin your pancreas is actually making. It’s especially helpful when deciding whether medications that stimulate insulin release make sense.
HOMA-IR
Calculated from fasting glucose and insulin, this gives a clearer picture of insulin resistance severity.
Oral Glucose Tolerance Test (with insulin levels)
When insulin is measured alongside glucose at multiple time points, delayed or absent Phase 1 insulin response often becomes visible—something fasting labs can miss.
Continuous Glucose Monitoring (CGM)
While not diagnostic, CGMs reveal patterns no lab can show: stress spikes, dawn phenomenon, exercise response, and whether food is truly the main driver.
Cortisol Testing
This is the elephant in the room. Chronic stress increases liver glucose output, suppresses insulin release, and worsens medication side effects. When cortisol is high, treatment can feel like pushing a boulder uphill.
Testing doesn’t eliminate the need for adjustment—but it turns blind trial into informed experimentation.
Stress and the Nervous System Affect Diabetes Medications
Here’s the part many women intuitively know but rarely hear validated:
The nervous system is part of glucose regulation.
When the body is in a chronic state of threat—overwork, caregiving, perfectionism, financial pressure—it prioritizes survival over balance. Cortisol rises. Glucose rises. Insulin signaling changes. Even well-matched medications can feel wrong.
This is why addressing stress isn’t a “nice add-on.” It’s foundational.
And no—this doesn’t mean diabetes is “all in your head.” It means your physiology is responding intelligently to the signals it’s receiving.
What This Information Is Meant to Do (and Not Do)
This article is not here to:
- Tell you to stop medication
- Replace medical advice
- Push one treatment over another
It is here to:
- Help you understand your body
- Normalize why certain meds felt wrong
- Encourage better questions
- Shift you from blame to biology
When women understand what part of the system needs support, they stop feeling like failures and start becoming collaborators in their care.
The Takeaway
Type 2 diabetes is not one disease with one solution. It’s a dynamic, stress-influenced metabolic adaptation—and medications are only one part of the picture.
When treatment aligns with physiology—and when stress and nervous system regulation are addressed alongside medical care—outcomes improve. Side effects lessen. And the experience becomes far less combative.
Understanding changes everything. Questions to ask your healthcare provider.
Divine Disruption 
Leave a comment